The Bagelry - Oakley

Arthur McNamara a month ago

Nothing better than finishing up a hard workout and stopping at one of the best bagel shops in all of Cincinnati: the Bagelry. I ordered the Gecco, which had Goetta, Egg, Cheddar, and Chive & Onion cream cheese (get it, GECCO) on an Everything Bagel. As a native Cincinnatian, Goetta is the heart and soul of breakfast, and the Bagelry has perfected the art of crispy, crunchy, yet soft and flavorful Goetta. The bagels alone are worth eating, made fresh New York-style.

Marc Slotnick 3 months ago

Great bagel place in Oakley, Cincinnati, Ohio. A wide variety of bagel sandwiches. We particularly came here for the everything gluten free bagels, which were wonderful. I had the NYC lox bagel which had lox, cream cheese, capers, tomatoes and onions. All perfectly went together and tomatoes were fresh. I previously had an egg and cheese on gluten free and was perfect as well. My wife had one of the regular bagel sandwiches and said the bagel was one of the best bagels she had. I highly recommend whether you are gluten free or not. This is more of a pickup location but there is about 16 seats inside and 12 outside. Look forward to our next visit.

Michael Martin 4 months ago

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ The Bagelry is outstanding. I had the NYC Lox and it was incredibly fresh and delicious. You can really tell the quality of the ingredients is top notch. One of the coolest things about this place is that they actually make the bagels right in the store, and you can taste the difference. Fresh bagels, great texture, and authentic flavor. This place is always busy for a reason. Definitely one of the best bagel spots around Cincinnati.

Matt Krachanko 6 months ago

I was looking for a breakfast spot with a good bagel and cream cheese and came across The Bagelry. Glad I decided to stop in. When I first walked in, there were a few people inside but no line. By the time I ordered and waited for my food, the line had grown to 10 to 20 people and stretched through the whole shop. Definitely a popular place. Even with that, my order only took about 10 minutes, and there were plenty of mobile orders being picked up too. I ordered an everything bagel with jalapeño garlic cream cheese and the NYC Lox on a plain bagel. The NYC Lox was really solid. The bagel was toasted just right, crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The salmon tasted fresh and clean, not fishy at all. The everything bagel with jalapeño garlic cream cheese was just as good. The bagel had a great texture and was easy to bite into, not overly thick or crusty like some everything bagels can be. The cream cheese was flavorful and savory with a nice mild kick. One tip: if you want that classic New York style bagel with a lot of cream cheese, ask for extra. It doesn’t cost more, but the standard amount is pretty moderate. Overall, a really good spot for bagels and worth a stop

Jane Choi Edited 7 months ago

Stopped by this bagel shop and was seriously impressed. I ordered the bacon avocado bagel sandwich with cheese and sriracha on the side, and it was incredibly tasty—fresh ingredients, great flavor, and perfectly balanced. You can tell they really care about quality. On top of that, the shop has great vibes: welcoming, cozy, and just an all-around pleasant place to be. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or hanging out for a bit, this spot is definitely worth a visit. Highly recommend!